Tesla trails Waymo says report, Apple’s big COVID-19 decisions, and more
Monday, March 16, 2020Morning! Keeping up with tech from my home office to yours. Hang in there.
Navigant Research published its annual leaderboard for the development of automated driving technology this morning, via CNET.
- While it doesn’t reflect commercial success or viability, it does paint a picture of the state of self-driving technology.
- The leaderboard isn’t just hardware/software technical competency but includes a range of factors such as production strategy, marketing, capability, staying power and reliability.
- Note this isn’t just about which company is right now capable of taking you furthest in its self-driving offering, but about a wider view of the ecosystem.
- The groups of companies are then classified on a map with axes for strategy and execution, which are subjective:
The map:
- The likes of Waymo, Cruise, Baidu (in China), and Ford rank as leaders in the top right of the graph, with Waymo leading on execution, and Ford slightly ahead on strategy, per the chart points.
- And then there’s Tesla, ranking the lowest on both overall measures, classed as a challenger.
- The difference from 2019 is the removal of Apple, Uber, and Lyft, which may no longer be working on the technology at any kind of reasonable scale.
- 2019’s leaderboard can be seen here, and shows Waymo has moved ahead.
- Volvo and the Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Alliance remain as challengers, too.
What gives?
- Navigant’s report explains: “Tesla continues to make high-profile promises, including having one million robotaxi-capable vehicles on the road by the end of 2020. However, the performance of its systems remains inconsistent and its products do not match its proposed mobility business model."
- Note that in previous years, Navigant clarified its stance to explain that rankings are based on “developing the technology and having a business model to generate cash”.
So, is Navigant being too harsh?
- Each year this is a hotly debated report.
- Navigant’s report has always been hard on Tesla, mostly for overpromising, which mostly seems to come from Elon Musk, who by now people should know to take with a grain or two of salt.
- In any case, expect this latest effort from Navigant to attract plenty of comment and discussion over the next few days.
- One last thing: Navigant's full report cost will be in the range of ~$4,000. It helps to make it slightly controversial to get people to buy in, it should be noted
Round Up:
๐คณ Crazy idea: Why don’t we scrap selfie cameras completely? (Android Authority).
๐งช Verily, an Alphabet moonshot company, has launched Project Baseline, a pilot COVID-19 screening and testing website in the San Francisco Bay Area. Get screened and get tested for free, if you live in the project areas. Somewhat dubiously, Project Baseline first asks you to sign in with your Google account. That’s a privacy risk and not HIPAA-compliant (projectbaseline.com, more about the project here).
