Hollow Knight: Silksong Lore Theories – Connecting Silksong to Hollow Knight

The world of Hollow Knight is rich with mystery, lore, and intricate connections that have captivated players since the original game's release. With the arrival of Hollow Knight: Silksong, fans have been diving deep into the new kingdom of Pharloom, uncovering clues and connections that bind the two games together. The community has been buzzing with theories attempting to decipher how Silksong connects to the original Hollow Knight, what this means for the broader universe, and what secrets Team Cherry has hidden beneath the surface.

In this comprehensive exploration of Silksong lore theories, we'll delve into the most compelling fan theories from Reddit, YouTube, and community forums, while adding our own analysis based on in-game evidence. Whether you're a lore enthusiast or simply curious about the deeper connections between these two masterpieces, join us as we unravel the threads that weave Hallownest and Pharloom together.

The Geographical Connection: Hallownest and Pharloom

One of the most fundamental questions surrounding Silksong is its relationship to Hallownest. Are these two separate kingdoms, or are they connected in ways we haven't yet discovered?

Theory: Pharloom Exists Above Hallownest

The most widely accepted theory is that Pharloom is located above Hallownest, potentially on the surface world. This theory is supported by several clues:

Environmental Differences: Pharloom features more open-air environments and natural light, contrasting with Hallownest's underground setting.
The Ascending Theme: Hornet's journey in Silksong involves moving upward through various levels of Pharloom, suggesting a vertical relationship with Hallownest.
References to "Above": Several NPCs in Silksong mention "the kingdom below" or "the buried kingdom," hinting at Hallownest's location beneath Pharloom.

This theory suggests that the events of Silksong are happening simultaneously with or shortly after the original Hollow Knight, with the infection potentially spreading upward to Pharloom.

Our Analysis

The evidence for this connection is compelling, especially when considering how Hornet, who was born in Hallownest, now finds herself in Pharloom. The vertical relationship between the two kingdoms would explain how characters and elements from the original game could appear or be referenced in Silksong. Additionally, the idea of the infection spreading upward creates a natural narrative bridge between the two games, raising the stakes for both kingdoms.

Hornet's True Origins and Purpose

Hornet's role in Silksong raises many questions about her true origins and the purpose of her journey to Pharloom. While we know she's the daughter of the Pale King and the Beast of Deepnest, her connection to Pharloom remains mysterious.

Theory: Hornet Was Sent to Pharloom to Stop the Infection

Popular theory suggests that Hornet was specifically chosen to travel to Pharloom to prevent the infection from taking hold there. This theory is based on:

Hornet's Immunity: As a half-spider, half-bug hybrid, Hornet possesses natural resistance to the infection that plagues Hallownest.
The Weavers' Knowledge: The Weavers of Pharloom seem to recognize Hornet and possess knowledge of her origins, suggesting a pre-existing connection.
The Opening Cinematic: Silksong begins with Hornet being captured and taken to Pharloom against her will, implying that someone or something didn't want her to fulfill her mission.

This theory positions Hornet as a crucial figure in the fight against the infection, potentially more important than even the Knight in the original game.

Our Analysis

The evidence for Hornet's special role is strong throughout Silksong. Her unique abilities and the way other characters react to her suggest she has a specific purpose in Pharloom. The idea that she was sent to stop the infection aligns with her character's established traits as a protector and fighter. However, the question remains: who sent her? The Pale King? The Weavers? Or some other force with knowledge of both kingdoms?

The Infection's Presence in Pharloom

One of the most debated aspects of Silksong is whether the infection that devastated Hallownest has spread to Pharloom. The evidence is mixed, leading to several competing theories.

Theory: The Infection Has Already Reached Pharloom

Some players believe the infection is already present in Pharloom, pointing to:

Corrupted Enemies: Several enemies in Silksong display orange, glowing eyes similar to infected creatures in Hollow Knight.
The "Orange Blood": Certain areas feature pools of orange fluid that resembles the infection's manifestation in Hallownest.
Infected Bosses: Some bosses in Silksong exhibit behavior and appearance consistent with infection, such as the Radiance and her followers.

This theory suggests that the infection has already taken hold in Pharloom, making Hornet's mission even more urgent.

Theory: Pharloom Has Its Own Form of Corruption

Alternatively, some theorists believe that Pharloom has its own form of corruption separate from the infection:

Silk-Based Corruption: The corruption in Pharloom appears to be related to silk and weaving rather than the orange infection of Hallownest.
Different Origins: NPCs in Silksong refer to their corruption as "the blight" or "the tangle," suggesting a different phenomenon.
The Weavers' Role: The Weavers seem to have their own relationship with this corruption, implying it's native to Pharloom rather than spread from Hallownest.

This theory posits that Pharloom has its own problems separate from Hallownest's infection, though they may be related in ways we don't yet understand.

Our Analysis

After examining the evidence, it seems likely that both forms of corruption exist in Pharloom. The orange infection from Hallownest appears to have spread to some extent, but Pharloom also has its own silk-based corruption. The interaction between these two forces may be central to the plot of Silksong, potentially creating a new, more dangerous form of corruption that threatens both kingdoms.

The Pale King and White Lady's Connection to Pharloom

The Pale King and White Lady are central figures in Hollow Knight's lore, but their connection to Pharloom remains shrouded in mystery. Several theories attempt to explain their relationship to the new kingdom.

Theory: The Pale King Originated from Pharloom

One compelling theory suggests that the Pale King originally came from Pharloom before establishing Hallownest:

Wyrm Origins: The Pale King was originally a Wyrm, and some evidence suggests that Wyrms may have originated in Pharloom before migrating to Hallownest.
The Pale King's Knowledge: The Pale King's advanced knowledge of the void and soul magic may have been learned in Pharloom, where such arts seem more developed.
The White Lady's Presence: The White Lady appears in Silksong through various references, suggesting she may have followed the Pale King from Pharloom to Hallownest.

This theory would explain the Pale King's power and knowledge while creating a direct connection between the two kingdoms' rulers.

Theory: The Pale King Was Fleeing Pharloom

Alternatively, some believe the Pale King was fleeing something in Pharloom when he established Hallownest:

The Weavers' Animosity: The Weavers of Pharloom seem to have a negative view of the Pale King, suggesting a past conflict.
Hallownest as a Refuge: Hallownest's underground location may have been chosen as a refuge from threats in Pharloom.
The Void Connection: The Pale King's experimentation with the void may have been an attempt to create defenses against Pharloom-based threats.

This theory positions Hallownest as a sanctuary created by the Pale King to escape dangers in Pharloom, with the infection being an unintended consequence of his experiments.

Our Analysis

Both theories have merit, and elements of each may be true. The Pale King likely had connections to Pharloom before establishing Hallownest, and he may have been fleeing some threat while also seeking to create a new kingdom. The Weavers' knowledge of the Pale King and the void suggests a complex history between the two kingdoms that we've only begun to uncover.

The Void's Role in Pharloom

The void is a central element in Hollow Knight's lore, but its presence and role in Silksong are less clear. Several theories attempt to explain how the void functions in Pharloom and its connection to the original game.

Theory: The Void Originated in Pharloom

Some theorists believe that the void, which plays such a crucial role in Hallownest, actually originated in Pharloom:

The Abyss Connection: The Abyss in Hallownest may have been created as a connection to a deeper void source in Pharloom.
The Weavers' Void Knowledge: The Weavers demonstrate knowledge of the void and its properties, suggesting they've studied it for generations.
Void-Based Enemies: Several enemies in Silksong use void-like attacks, implying the void exists in Pharloom in some form.

This theory would explain why the Pale King was so interested in the void and how he learned to harness its power.

Theory: The Void Is Spreading to Pharloom

Alternatively, some believe the void is spreading from Hallownest to Pharloom, potentially as a consequence of the Knight's actions in the original game:

Void Leaks: Certain areas in Silksong feature void-like substances that seem to be seeping in from below.
The Knight's Journey: The Knight's actions in Hollow Knight may have weakened the barriers between the void and other kingdoms.
The Void's Influence: Some NPCs in Silksong mention "the creeping darkness" or "the hungry emptiness," possibly referring to the void.

This theory suggests that the void is becoming a problem beyond Hallownest, with potentially catastrophic consequences for Pharloom.

Our Analysis

The evidence suggests that the void exists in both kingdoms but may function differently in each. In Hallownest, the void was harnessed by the Pale King for specific purposes, while in Pharloom, it seems to have a more natural, wild existence. The interaction between these two manifestations of the void could be central to the plot of Silksong and its connection to the original game.

The Weavers and Their True Purpose

The Weavers are one of the most mysterious factions in Silksong, and their true purpose and connection to the original game are subjects of intense speculation.

Theory: The Weavers Are Fighting the Infection

Many players believe the Weavers are actively fighting against the spread of the infection in Pharloom:

Weaver Tools: The Weavers possess tools and abilities specifically designed to combat corruption and infection.
Weaver Dialogue: Several Weavers mention their duty to "preserve the pattern" or "maintain the weave," possibly referring to fighting corruption.
Hornet's Alliance: Hornet's ability to work with the Weavers suggests they share a common enemy in the infection.

This theory positions the Weavers as crucial allies in the fight against the infection, potentially holding knowledge that could help Hornet save both kingdoms.

Theory: The Weavers Caused the Infection

Conversely, some theorists believe the Weavers may have inadvertently caused the infection:

Weaver Experiments: Evidence suggests the Weavers were conducting experiments with silk and soul energy that may have gone wrong.
The Radiance's Connection: The Radiance appears to have some connection to the Weavers, possibly as a failed experiment or creation.
The Weavers' Secrecy: The Weavers are secretive about their past actions, suggesting they may be hiding something significant.

This darker interpretation suggests that the Weavers may be responsible for the very problems they're now trying to solve.

Our Analysis

The truth likely lies somewhere between these two theories. The Weavers probably were experimenting with powers they didn't fully understand, leading to unintended consequences. Now, they're trying to contain the damage while also helping Hornet find a more permanent solution. This complex moral position makes them one of the most interesting factions in the Silksong universe.

The Radiance and Her Influence in Pharloom

The Radiance, the primary antagonist of Hollow Knight, makes several appearances in Silksong, raising questions about her role in the new kingdom.

Theory: The Radiance Originated in Pharloom

Some theorists believe the Radiance, or the being that would become the Radiance, originated in Pharloom:

Moth References: Pharloom contains numerous references to moths and light beings that predate the Radiance's appearance in Hallownest.
The Weavers' Knowledge: The Weavers seem to have knowledge of the Radiance and her weaknesses, suggesting a long history.
Light-Based Magic: Pharloom features more light-based magic than Hallownest, possibly indicating the Radiance's place of origin.

This theory would explain the Radiance's power and why she was able to infect Hallownest so easily.

Theory: The Radiance Is Spreading to Pharloom

Alternatively, some believe the Radiance is spreading from Hallownest to Pharloom, possibly following Hornet or through some other means:

Infected Areas: Certain areas in Silksong show signs of Radiance-like corruption, with light-based enemies and environments.
The Radiance's Followers: Several enemies in Silksong appear to be followers of the Radiance, suggesting her influence is growing.
Hornet's Visions: Hornet experiences visions of the Radiance throughout her journey, possibly indicating a psychic connection.

This theory suggests that defeating the Radiance in Hallownest wasn't enough to stop her entirely.

Our Analysis

The evidence suggests that the Radiance has connections to both kingdoms but may have originated in Pharloom. Her influence in Hallownest may have been an extension of her power from Pharloom, and her defeat in the original game may have weakened but not eliminated her. This sets up an interesting dynamic where Hornet must deal with the lingering effects of the Radiance while also confronting new threats in Pharloom.

The Possible Return of the Knight

One of the most exciting theories circulating in the community is the possible return of the Knight from Hollow Knight in Silksong.

Theory: The Knight Will Appear as an Ally or Boss

Many players believe the Knight will make an appearance in Silksong, either as an ally to Hornet or as a boss fight:

Void Connections: Several void-based areas in Silksong suggest the Knight may have found a way to travel between kingdoms.
The Knight's Fate: The true ending of Hollow Knight left the Knight's fate ambiguous, allowing for a return in Silksong.
Co-op Potential: Some evidence suggests the possibility of co-op gameplay, with the Knight and Hornet fighting together.

This theory has generated enormous excitement among fans, who would love to see these two characters interact.

Theory: The Knight Is Already in Pharloom

Some more radical theorists believe the Knight is already in Pharloom in some form:

The Hollow Knight Boss: The Hollow Knight boss fight in Silksong may actually be the Knight, corrupted or transformed.
Vessel References: Several NPCs mention "the empty vessel" or "the silent warrior," possibly referring to the Knight.
The Void Entity: A mysterious void-based entity that appears in certain areas may be the Knight in a different form.

This theory suggests a more tragic fate for the Knight, who may have become lost or corrupted while traveling to Pharloom.

Our Analysis

While the idea of the Knight appearing in Silksong is exciting, the evidence remains circumstantial. Team Cherry is known for their subtle storytelling, so it's possible the Knight's presence is hinted at rather than explicitly shown. Whether as an ally, boss, or background element, the Knight's connection to Pharloom remains one of the most intriguing aspects of Silksong's lore.

The Nature of Pharloom's Rulers

The rulers of Pharloom remain mysterious, with several theories attempting to identify them and their connection to Hallownest's royalty.

Theory: Pharloom Is Ruled by the Weavers

Some players believe the Weavers are the de facto rulers of Pharloom:

Weaver Authority: The Weavers appear to have authority throughout Pharloom, with other NPCs deferring to them.
Palace Connections: The Bloom Palace, which seems to be Pharloom's seat of power, is closely associated with the Weavers.
Weaver Magic: The Weavers possess powerful magic that suggests royal or noble status.

This theory positions the Weavers as the ruling class of Pharloom, possibly with a queen or king at their head.

Theory: Pharloom Has No Single Ruler

Alternatively, some believe Pharloom has no single ruler but is instead governed by a council or collective:

Council References: Several NPCs mention "the council" or "the assembly," suggesting a collective leadership structure.
Regional Differences: Different areas of Pharloom seem to have different governing structures, implying a decentralized power system.
The Weavers' Role: The Weavers may be advisors or guardians rather than rulers, serving a higher authority or collective.

This theory suggests a more complex political structure in Pharloom than the monarchy of Hallownest.

Our Analysis

The evidence suggests that Pharloom's political structure is indeed more complex than Hallownest's monarchy. The Weavers appear to hold significant power and influence, but they may not be the sole rulers. The true nature of Pharloom's governance remains one of the most intriguing unanswered questions in Silksong's lore.

How the Endings Connect to Hollow Knight

Silksong features multiple endings, and each potentially connects back to the original game in different ways. Theories about these connections abound in the community.

Theory: The True Ending Sets Up a Sequel

Many players believe the true ending of Silksong sets up a direct sequel that would feature both Hallownest and Pharloom:

Kingdom Connections: The true ending reveals direct connections between the two kingdoms, suggesting they're more closely linked than previously believed.
Character Returns: Several characters from both games appear in the true ending, hinting at future interactions.
New Threat: The true ending introduces a new threat that affects both kingdoms, setting up a larger conflict for a potential sequel.

This theory has generated excitement about the possibility of a larger Hollow Knight universe that spans multiple kingdoms.

Theory: The Secret Ending Reveals the Knight's Fate

Some theorists believe the secret ending of Silksong finally reveals what happened to the Knight after the events of Hollow Knight:

The Knight's Appearance: The secret ending features a character who appears to be the Knight, confirming their survival.
Void Connection: The secret ending explores the void's connection between the two kingdoms, with the Knight playing a crucial role.
Future Team-Up: The secret ending suggests a possible team-up between Hornet and the Knight in future content.

This theory provides closure for fans who have wondered about the Knight's fate since the original game.

Our Analysis

The endings of Silksong do indeed connect back to Hollow Knight in meaningful ways, with the true and secret endings providing the most significant links. These connections suggest that Team Cherry has a larger vision for the Hollow Knight universe, with Silksong being just one part of a larger narrative. Whether we'll see a direct sequel or more games set in this universe remains to be seen, but the endings certainly leave the door open for future exploration.

Conclusion: The Interwoven Kingdoms

As we've explored throughout this article, the connections between Hollow Knight and Silksong are numerous, complex, and fascinating. From geographical relationships to character connections, from the spread of the infection to the nature of the void, Team Cherry has crafted a rich, interconnected universe that rewards careful exploration and speculation.

The theories discussed here represent just a fraction of the lore discussions happening in the community. As players continue to explore Pharloom and uncover its secrets, new theories will emerge, and existing ones will be refined or debunked. This ongoing conversation is a testament to the depth and quality of Team Cherry's world-building.

What do you think about these theories? Do you have your own ideas about how Silksong connects to Hollow Knight? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and join the community in unraveling the mysteries of these two extraordinary kingdoms.

As we continue to explore the world of Pharloom, one thing is certain: the connections between Hallownest and Pharloom run deep, and the full story of these interwoven kingdoms has yet to be fully revealed. Until then, the theories and speculation will continue to enrich our understanding and appreciation of this remarkable universe.